Select Page

DENSO P1 SYSTEM BOLT CORROSION TESTING REPORT

BACKGROUND

In the water industry it is common to install pipeline fittings with either plain stainless-steel bolts or differing steel grade bolts protected by a factory coating. While the fitting itself is often protected from corrosion by more robust means, the bolts are often overlooked and left without sufficient corrosion protection. Any corrosion protection provided by factory coatings can be easily damaged in transit or during installation. The unprotected bolts provide an opportunity for destructive corrosion to occur, leading to bolt failure and in turn, potentially dangerous and costly incidents. To combat this issue, Denso recommends the Denso P1 System, designed for the protection of ferrous pipes, joints and fittings within the water industry in accordance with ‘Civil Engineering Specification for the Water Industry – 8th Edition’. It comprises a coat of Denso Paste followed by the use of Denso Profiling Mastic to fill any voids over joints to form a smooth profile. The system is completed by the application of a double layer of Denso Tape.

Denso Paste being applied as part of the Denso P1 System

1. Denso Paste is used to create the initial layer of corrosion prevention in the complex surfaces.

Denso Profiling Mastic being applied as part of the Denso P1 System

2. Application of Denso Profiling Mastic to fill any voids and create a smooth profile for wrapping the fitting.

Denso Tape Mastic being applied as to finish the Denso P1 System

3. A complete Denso P1 System after the application of Denso Tape, applied with a 55% overlap.

TESTING

In this investigation, bolts were installed onto a small-scale version of a common water pipeline fitting and Salt Spray testing was performed to replicate a highly corrosive environment. Three different bolt types were tested to represent the commonly used bolt materials and factory coatings. Half of the samples were protected with the Denso P1 system, and the other half were left unprotected, as received from the supplier.

Note: Salt spray exposure was performed based on ASTM G85-19 (Annex A5, X6) for 2000h.

Fitting Paste and Mastic System - Denso

Denso Profiling Mastic applied to the test fitting after the torquing of bolts and application of Denso Paste.

Fitting Full System - Denso

Double layer of Denso Tape, applied spirally, to complete the system ready for salt spray testing.

RESULTS & CONCLUSIONS

The results demonstrate the severity of corrosion that can occur on bolts which are not protected by the Denso P1 System. All bolt types showed significant corrosion when unprotected however all the samples protected with the Denso P1 System did not display any signs of corrosion.

BOLT TYPE 1 UNPROTECTED

Steel grade 4.8 bolts with silver zinc / organic coating duplex system factory coating.

Note: Two further bolts not pictured were too corroded to be removed from the fitting.

Image Image

BOLT TYPE 1 PROTECTED

Steel grade 4.8 bolts with silver zinc / organic coating duplex system factory coating protected with Denso P1 System.

BOLT TYPE 2 UNPROTECTED

Steel grade 8.8 bolts with green zinc / organic coating duplex system factory coating.

Image Image

BOLT TYPE 2 PROTECTED

Steel grade 8.8 bolts with green zinc / organic coating duplex system factory coating protected with Denso P1 System.

BOLT TYPE 3 UNPROTECTED

Stainless steel A4-50 bolts with Dry Film Lubricant factory coating.

Image Image

BOLT TYPE 3 PROTECTED

Stainless steel A4-50 bolts with Dry Film Lubricant factory coating protected with Denso P1 System.

Image

BOLT TYPE 1 UNPROTECTED

Steel grade 4.8 bolts with silver zinc / organic coating duplex system factory coating.

Note: Two further bolts not pictured were too corroded to be removed from the fitting.

Image

BOLT TYPE 1 PROTECTED

Steel grade 4.8 bolts with silver zinc / organic coating duplex system factory coating protected with Denso P1 System.

Image

BOLT TYPE 2 UNPROTECTED

Steel grade 8.8 bolts with green zinc / organic coating duplex system factory coating.

Image

BOLT TYPE 2 PROTECTED

Steel grade 8.8 bolts with green zinc / organic coating duplex system factory coating protected with Denso P1 System.

Image

BOLT TYPE 3 UNPROTECTED

Stainless steel A4-50 bolts with Dry Film Lubricant factory coating.

Image

BOLT TYPE 3 PROTECTED

Stainless steel A4-50 bolts with Dry Film Lubricant factory coating protected with Denso P1 System.